Hail, Glorious Pile: New York’s Public Library Returns

After a three-year, $50 million restoration project, the renamed Schwarzman Building of the New York Public Library has received a spectacular facelift to bring it back to its original, brilliant white appearance. Even if you have never had the opportunity to visit the island of Manhattan, gentle reader, you are probably familiar with the library’s main building – oftentimes referred to as “The New York Public Library” even though this is simply the main branch – which sits majestically on Fifth Avenue at 42nd Street. The glorious beaux-arts building and its iconic pair of lions flanking the front steps have featured in countless major and minor films, from “42nd Street” to “Breakfast at Tiffany’s”, “Ghostbusters” to “The Thomas Crown Affair”. It is as symbolic of the City of New York as The Empire State Building, the Brooklyn Bridge, or St. Patrick’s Cathedral.

Construction began in 1902 and was completed in 1911, when President Taft came to dedicate the building. It was universally praised in its day and by many architectural critics now as being the most perfect example of beaux-arts architecture presently standing in the United States. When one thinks of this particular school of design in America, there is an inescapable connection made with the legendary firm of McKim, Mead, and White, the Rolls-Royce of beaux-arts architectural firms, and one could be forgiven for thinking that this masterpiece was their work.

Interestingly enough, however, the library was not designed by McKim, Mead, and White, but rather by the then-relatively unknown firm of Carrère and Hastings, an architectural partnership headed by John Merven Carrère and Thomas Hastings. The two men had met while studying at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts in Paris in the 1880s, and later both worked at McKim, Mead & White in New York. In 1885 they decided to leave the firm and go into practice together. For a number of years they built hotels and homes for wealthy clients, but it was the award of the New York Public Library commission in 1897 which catapulted them into prominence, much to the surprise of their better-known contemporaries and former employers.

As a result, Carrère and Hastings received numerous commissions for other prominent buildings across the country. Here in the Nation’s Capital, they designed Townsend House (now the home of the Cosmos Club), the Russell Senate Office Building, the Cannon House Office Building, and the Memorial Amphitheater in Arlington, where the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier is located. Moreover their influence, in competition with their former employers building in the capital as well, led to the adoption for a time of the beaux-arts aesthetic as the preferred architectural style of official Washington: a trend that continued, with some variation, in the construction of many public buildings and government offices in the city up until the shift toward ho-hum variations of international style, such as the K Street Box or the so-called “brutalist” architecture of the FBI headquarters.

Due in part to the early demise of both partners, Carrère and Hastings did not last as long as McKim, Mead & White. In addition, the decided objection of Hastings himself to the construction of buildings more than six stories tall came to be viewed as old-fashioned by a sort of skyscraper fetish, which began to dominate the skylines of major American cities in the 1890’s. This trend led to Congress passing the Height of Buildings Act of 1899 for Washington – more commonly known as The Cairo Act, after the offending apartment building which was felt to rise too tall. As a result, and no doubt influenced by architects like Thomas Hastings, Washington has retained a more human scale in its buildings, even as other cities created congested caverns which look beautiful from a distance but are oppressive when in their midst.

In some ways, the Main Building was both at the height of fashion and going out of fashion at the time it was built. Indeed, it may interest the reader to know that the same year ground was broken and the cornerstone laid at the Public Library, the landmark 22-story Flatiron Building – generally considered New York’s first true skyscraper – was completed. Two years after the Library was finished, the 57-story Woolworth Building became the tallest building in the world, which it remained until 1930. Today of course, the Library is now dwarfed by surrounding office towers, an oasis of architectural permanency and solidity amidst a desert of trendy construction ephemera. With this clean-up, let us hope it will continue to welcome, instruct and inspire visitors for another century to come.

Main Entrance to the New York Public Library

Poti Poti Friday

Lest my readers wonder why I am writing about bathroom fittings, I should explain that the term “poti poti” is a Catalan expression for a mixture of seemingly random things. In English, we might use the word “jumble”, or “mishmash”, while in French one might say “mélange” or “macédoine”. It is also the name of a dish, and a recipe for this is provided at the end of the entry.

Today there are a number of things which I would like to highlight for my readers:

– A hearty congratulations in advance to JB and his bride-to-be AD, whose wedding I will be attending this weekend, provided there are no further mishaps with the police. As I am with some regularity of late – bizarrely – mistaken for a police officer, perhaps I will prove of assistance in this regard. We shall see.

I am very much looking forward to the nuptial mass, and then moving on to the subsequent festivities at the beautiful Washington Club, a glorious Gilded Age mansion originally known as The Patterson House. It was designed by the legendary, albeit infamous Stanford White of New York’s beaux-arts masters McKim, Mead & White; it is the only example of White’s work here in the Capital. The home served as a temporary White House for President and Mrs. Coolidge in 1927, as the actual White House was being renovated.

– My congratulations also to Mr. and Mrs. Matthew Warner and family on the arrival of their new daughter Katherine Grace. Matt is a powerhouse of the Catholic blogosphere and runs the Fallible Blogma blog, among other ventures; his tweets in particular always alert me to interesting Catholic material on a daily basis. My best wishes to them and welcome to their new little one.

– Mr. Matthew Alderman over at Matthew Alderman Studios – and also of New Liturgical Movement and Shrine of the Holy Whapping fame – has released his Christmas Card design for this year. It is done in a charming Quattrocento woodcut style, and available to purchase online. While at the site you can also see Mr. Alderman’s proposed elevation for the new St. Paul University Catholic Center in Madison, Wisconsin, a very interesting blend of Romanesque, Byzantine, and Art Deco that reminds me (in overall impression, rather than stylistic elements) of a number of 1920’s and 1930’s campus buildings such as the Cathedral of Learning in Pittsburgh.

As to the recipe for poti poti, it is a favorite of mine which I hope my readers will enjoy. Technically it is considered a summer salad, but it is certainly tasty any time of the year. It is particularly useful if one wants to make use of bacallà, i.e., salted, dried cod (or even canned tuna, in a pinch) which is not often available in the States but seems to pop up more regularly in the winter. You can find it in many Italian or Latin American markets. In Italian it is known as “baccalà” and in Spanish as “bacalao”.

INGREDIENTS (for 4 persons)
1/2 pound of new or red potatoes, boiled and cooled
1/2 pound of dried cod, desalted (or canned tuna, drained)
2 hard-boiled eggs
2 tomatoes
1 green bell pepper
1 red bell pepper
1/2 medium-sized yellow onion
2 dozen pitted or pimiento stuffed olives
olive oil
vinegar (I prefer balsamic)
salt and pepper

NOTE: Optional extras for this jumble can include sliced sausage (preferably the white Catalan sausage known as botifarra, or a similar, mild but garlicky sausage) or diced/shredded cured ham such as serrano or prosciutto.

Slice the boiled potatoes into 1/4 inch discs, rinse them to remove any excess starch, pat them dry, and put aside into a separate bowl lined with paper towels. Cut the tomato into thin wedges and the bell peppers and onion into strips, and combine all of them in a large bowl. At this point, you can either add the olives directly to the pepper-tomato-onion mixture, or you can chop them into halves or quarters first before combining. Cut the hard-boiled eggs into 1/4 inch slices, and add these and the flaked cod (or tuna) to the bowl, stirring everything gently together to combine with a rubber spatula, being careful not to break up the tomatoes and eggs too much, and put this bowl aside as well.

Make a simple vinaigrette using the olive oil, balsamic vinegar, parsley, salt and pepper. Now add the dried-off potatoes into the large bowl with the other ingredients, and pour the vinaigrette over the top. Use a rubber spatula to combine everything.

At this point I would normally pack everything tightly into a bowl and put it in the fridge for at least an hour, and then unmould the salad by inverting it onto a plate. You can also cover the salad with plastic wrap and allow it to marinate at room temperature. Bon profit!

Stand selling bacallà in La Boqueria Market, Barcelona

>New Penn Station Finally Underway

>Although it will take a decade to complete, construction on the expansion of Pennsylvania Station in Manhattan is finally underway. The city held a groundbreaking ceremony at the James Farley Post Office yesterday, which will serve as an expansion of the important rail terminal across the street. The addition will be named for the late New York U.S. Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan – not one of my favorite people, admittedly, but an individual certainly of great importance to the history of New York.

Those who are not armchair architectural historians may not be aware that the site which now holds Penn Station (as it is more commonly referred to) and Madison Square Garden, was once home to a magnificent Beaux-Arts building. The old station was designed by the august American architectural firm of McKim, Mead & White, who built some of the most beautiful and iconic buildings in the country. The group designed Washington Arch in Washington Square Park in Greenwich Village; the Boston Public Library, about which I have written previously; and the West Wing of the White House here in Washington, D.C.

The destruction of the old Penn Station in the 1960’s is generally regarded as one of the great architectural crimes of American history. Although there were efforts to stop the demolition at the time, these were not effective as the concept of historic preservation in our larger cities was still something of a foreign concept to many government officials and the general public. When a building was perceived as being out of fashion, or its functions and appearance were deteriorating, it was often thought easier to simply tear the whole thing down, rather than renovate and restore. One still sees a great deal of this mentality in images of what has happened to historic Asian cities such as Shanghai.

The reaction to what happened to Penn Station proves the old adage that sometimes one has to lose something in order to appreciate it, once it is gone. As a result, when similar rumblings were made a few years after the destruction of Penn Station to tear down the smaller but equally beautiful Grand Central Terminal, prominent New Yorkers, architects, and historians rallied to fight the demolition and redevelopment of the site. Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis was one of those who used her influence to great effect in this regard, and no doubt this is one reason why she was particularly beloved by the people of New York City.

It is admittedly far too easy to criticize what was built in place of Penn Station, but let’s do so anyway: where to begin? There are the oddly placed stairwells and escalators leading into and out of the station which are inconvenient and make no sense. There is the awful pebble-dash-and-concrete sort of cladding with a lack of fenestration that makes the station look like a small, liberal college sports arena in the Midwest. There are the odd angles and curves of both interior and exterior walls where one can neither sit nor rest a bag, but which attract vagrants for the purposes of relieving themselves in shadowy corners in the middle of the day.

All of it is awful, and frankly all of it should be torn down. It is the secular equivalent of what was done to many churches in the 1960’s after Vatican II, when the faithful often did more damage than any militant atheist could have, as I wrote about yesterday on my other blog. The 1910 station was built to last a thousand years; the 1964 station was built to remind us of society’s collective ignorance for at least that long.

Fortunately, the new station will be located in a beautiful and impressive building not unlike the original station, and also designed by McKim, Mead & White. Although the conversion of a building designed to function as a giant mail depot will no doubt have certain problems, I suspect that it will be far easier than dealing with a similar structure designed as a bank, for example. The post office needs to get men, trucks, and carts in and out in as efficient a manner possible; doing the same with human beings carrying wheeled luggage or baggage carts is not really much of a functional shift. And being able to arrive and depart from Midtown Manhattan once again at a beautiful meeting place will no doubt cheer the traveler in ways which the current structure utterly fails to do.

Interior of Pennsylvania Station, as it was