Come and See: The Challenge of Pope Francis’ Papacy

Today Catholics everywhere will be reading about how Pope Francis has won a beauty contest sponsored by TIME magazine, a publication which spends much of its time working diligently to undermine the work of the Church over the past two millenia.  I realize that I will be expected by many to toe to some sort of accepted Catholic line here, about how great it is that people are paying attention to the Church because of this particular Pope, and how this pontificate is so full of – ahem – hope and change.  I regret to inform the reader that he will probably be disappointed.

Having read the four-page TIME cover piece on Pope Francis, I was as an initial matter struck by the fact that the secular media is absolutely obsessed with sex.  This should perhaps come as no surprise, since one could hardly expect a leopard to change its spots.  For all the oft-heard characterization of Catholics as being trapped in some sort of repressive timewarp, the Catholics in my circle seem to have a far better-integrated understanding of their own sexuality than those who have an insatiable need to talk not only about theirs, but everyone else’s all the time.

It also struck me as a bit strange that TIME would title their cover piece as: “Pope Francis, the People’s Pope”.  Who else’s would he be, exactly?  The title brings to mind the media-induced wailing that occurred upon the death of Diana, “The People’s Princess”, and betrays a fundamental lack of understanding of the role of the Supreme Pontiff in the Church.

I would imagine that the present Holy Father himself would be the first to say that the real “Person of the Year”, and indeed of every year, is of course Jesus Christ.  Pope Francis is simply His instrument, charged with the (unenviable) duty of shepherding His flock.  In imitation of Christ, the Pope tries to follow the instruction given at the Last Supper that “I have given you a model to follow, so that as I have done for you, you should also do.  Amen, amen, I say to you, no slave is greater than his master nor any messenger greater than the one who sent him.” (St. John 13:15-16)  From what I have seen so far, this Pope is doing an excellent job of making all of us feel decidedly uncomfortable about whether we are being a useful servant.

At the same time however, one needs to be careful in noting that being elected pope does not mean that one becomes a saint.  There are many saintly popes, for example Pope St. Damasus I whose feast day is today, and there are also many less-than-saintly ones.  There are popes who were personally popular but spiritually lazy, and popes possessing great personal sanctity whom no one particularly liked.  It is far too soon for us to have an assessment of Pope Francis’ papacy, which is not even a year old.  Whatever secular attention this Pope is receiving at the moment, his personal popularity among those who would never darken the door of a church, let alone a confessional, is completely irrelevant if that is all it remains.

And here, like it or not, is where you come in.  It would be ludicrous to suggest that it is solely Pope Francis’ job to get people in the pews.  How very easy it is to armchair quarterback this Pope and say, he should be doing this or he should not be doing that, thereby setting yourself up as your own sort of Antipope.  Yet if you are not out there evangelizing to others, in the myriad of ways by which one can do so in one’s daily life, I will not be particularly impressed by your prognostications on whether Pope Francis will create women cardinals or rent out the Papal Apartments for parties.

Truthfully the TIME honor is not so terrible, as far as back-handed compliments go.  However now that everyone at the office or the grocery store is talking about the head of the Catholic Church, you have an opportunity to flesh out the very incomplete portrait painted by this magazine and the secular media in general.  For in the end, not surprisingly, TIME got it wrong.  The theme of this papacy is clearly not, “Who am I to judge?”, but rather, “Come and see.”


12 thoughts on “Come and See: The Challenge of Pope Francis’ Papacy

  1. Yes, to satisfy the secular and liberal audience that Time writes to, the selection of Pope Francis as their Person of the Year had to be qualified. I was pretty disheartened listening to the video posted alongside the article when it veered into political issues. Why is it so hard for some to grasp that the Catholic Church is not a political party?
    I have very mixed feelings about this and really appreciate your insights here!


  2. All our dear Pope is saying is live the life Christ calls us to. Be faithful to the Truth and speak whenever it is necessary to shed light on any misinformation out there, and; there certainly is a lot of misinformation. Just live our lives in such and exemplary fashion that others are curious and drawn to the presence of Jesus in us. Lord grant me the grace to be a witness of Your Love in a world so full of confusion, help me to shed Your Light where there is so much darkness and assist me with Your Courage to speak whenever necessary!


  3. I admit, I started your blog post with some hesitation thinking it would be more, “Pope Francis is liberal and destroying the Church, and now look — he’s on the cover of TIME!!” I was pleasantly surprised, and am very grateful for your insights. Such a great point: it’s up to us to get people into the pews, to encourage the people we meet to check out the Church, or to return to the sacraments if they’ve been away. And we should be helping others dive more deeply into the lessons of this Pontificate.

    Anyway…that’s a long-winded way of saying “thank you.” Keep up the good writing!


  4. Pingback: “Why Pope Francis Is Really The 2014 Person Of The Year” | Sunset Daily

  5. Pingback: Time Magazine's Man of the Year is Pope Francis. Alas, it's not the real Pope Francis – Telegraph Blogs

  6. Pingback: Is that Really Pope Francis?

  7. “Toe the line,” not “tow the line.” We’re not dragging a boat, we’re toeing up to the line at the start of a race. Yet another product of outstanding Jesuit education.


      • More precisely, it’s one of many many English idioms taken from the great naval tradition of England. To “toe the line” was to literally put your toes up to a line drawn on a deck when standing at attention. So when someone ‘toes the line’ they are simply obeying without question, thus the idiom. Not mentioned a lot in O’Brien but I do recall reading it once or twice there.


  8. Pingback: Like Pope Francis? You’ll LOVE Jesus | Lee Hernly

  9. Pingback: CW202: Religious and Lay Dominican Orders | SQPN: Catholic WeekendCW202: Religious and Lay Dominican Orders - SQPN: Catholic Weekend

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s